Little Silver has a new place to eat by the train. NJ.com reported on October 31 that Locale Pizzeria & Market is operating at 24 Ayers Lane, across from the NJ Transit station and a couple of blocks from the original Locale restaurant at 51 Oceanport Ave. It has 26 seats, takes no reservations and closes at 10 p.m.
Those details matter because of what was proposed for this block before. Seven years ago the plan here was an 11,000-square-foot tavern with three bars, room for 250 people and a 2 a.m. closing time. Neighbors fought it until it was withdrawn. What the station area has now is two places run by the same family: a sit-down restaurant at 51 Oceanport Ave. and a counter across from the train lot. That is about the scale the opponents said they wanted from the start.
What Opened on Ayers Lane
The new spot is the casual sibling of Locale, the Italian restaurant on Oceanport Avenue. According to NJ.com, it runs on a different schedule and serves a different menu from the original.
- Hours. The market opens at 7 a.m. and the pizzeria at 10 a.m. Both close at 10 p.m.
- Pizza. The counter sells 16-inch pies and slices. The restaurant serves 12-inch Napoletana pies. Choices include plain, Margherita, Chicken Parm, Quattro Formaggi and Mike's Hot Pepperoni.
- Sandwiches. The menu lists 14 panuozzi, including one with mortadella, stracciatella and pistachio cream.
- Market shelves. Pasta made on-site, fresh-baked bread, grab-and-go prepared food, and cheese and produce from Livoti's Old World Market.
- Delivery and catering. Delivery runs through DoorDash, Uber Eats and Slice, and the kitchen also caters.
The 7 a.m. opening puts fresh bread and prepared food across the street from the station's main commuter lot before the morning trains. NJ.com also notes there is parking right out front.
Locale was opened by siblings Giuseppe Ottaiano Jr., Tom Ottaiano and Natalie Priore. The family also runs pizza counters inside Livoti's Old World Market locations in Brick, Freehold and Middletown, so a counter-service format is familiar to them.
The Tavern That Was Supposed to Be Here
The first serious plan for this corner looked nothing like a 26-seat counter. Two River Times reported in May 2019 on the proposal for 51 Oceanport Ave., a 0.63-acre lot near the station. It called for a two-story Brickwall Tavern with two bars on the first floor, a third bar on a second-floor outdoor balcony and a maximum capacity of 250. The doors would have closed to customers at 2 a.m., with the last employees out by 3 a.m.
Parking was the other problem. Borough ordinance required 230 spaces for the project, and the site plan had 36 on the property. The applicant's answer was a letter of intent from NJ Transit that would have let overflow cars use the commuter lot next door. Residents worried about late-night noise from the balcony and about cars leaving the lot onto Oceanport Avenue and cutting back through town toward Red Bank, Fair Haven and Rumson. Fifteen members of the Townhomes at Little Silver hired a lawyer to represent them at the hearings.
After two years of planning board meetings, the application was withdrawn in April 2019. One member of the opposition group summed up the objection in an interview with Two River Times:
"We were never opposed to having something at that site. But the scale of the project and the hours of operation really didn't fit with the makeup of the town. I think people were expecting a normal-sized restaurant to go there."
Here is how that 2019 proposal compares with what operates near the station now.
| Proposed Brickwall Tavern, 2019 | Locale Pizzeria & Market, 2026 | |
|---|---|---|
| Location | 51 Oceanport Ave. | 24 Ayers Lane |
| Capacity | 250 patrons maximum | 26 seats |
| Closing time | 2 a.m. to customers | 10 p.m. |
| Format | Three bars and an outdoor balcony | Counter service, no reservations |
The 51 Oceanport Ave. lot did get a restaurant in the end. It is Locale, a sit-down Italian restaurant, which is much closer to the "normal-sized restaurant" neighbors had in mind than the plan they fought.
One License, a Decade of Steps
The tavern fight was one chapter of a longer story about a single liquor license. Little Silver was never completely dry. Little Silver Liquors already held a package-goods license at 497 Prospect Ave., according to Two River Times. What the borough lacked for decades was a license that let a restaurant or bar serve drinks on site. Earlier efforts to change that failed in the 1970s and early 1980s.
The steps from there to two Locale storefronts went like this:
- November 2015. Voters passed a binding referendum, 742 to 692, directing the borough to create and auction one on-premises consumption license, as redbankgreen reported. The council still had to change zoning before a restaurant or bar could use it.
- December 2016. Brick Wall at Little Silver LLC was the only qualified bidder at auction and paid $350,000 for the license.
- April 2019. After the tavern application was withdrawn, the license was issued in "pocket status," meaning it was not tied to any address in the borough.
- May 2019. The council voted 5-0 to issue the license to BrickWall with a condition that it be active by June 20, 2021. If it was not attached to an identified site, the council could refuse renewal and seek revocation.
- March 25, 2024. The council approved a person-to-person transfer of the license from Brickwall at Little Silver, LLC to the Locale entity.
- October 7, 2024. The council approved moving the license out of pocket status and placing it at 51 Oceanport Ave., according to borough minutes.
- December 2024. Locale opened on Oceanport Avenue. In August 2025, NJ.com described it as the only restaurant in town with a liquor license.
The announcement of Locale's opening credited Matthew and Michael Kelly, local builders and community advocates, with a campaign of nearly a decade to bring a license to town. It described their goal as creating a local gathering place. That goal is the same one the 2019 opponents described. The two sides disagreed about scale, and the version that got built is the smaller one.
The restaurant also leans on its own neighborhood. "Everything about this place is local," Ottaiano told NJ.com in 2025. He described a vegetable garden out back, meat from the Butcher's Block in Long Branch, seafood from the Highlands and in-house mozzarella and pasta. The new market on Ayers Lane puts that in-house pasta and bread on a counter where you can pick it up on the way home.
The Station Next Door This Month
The pizzeria sits across from the busiest parking in town. NJ Transit places Little Silver Station on Branch Avenue between Sycamore and Oceanport Avenues. Its station page lists 518 NJ Transit spaces in the Ayers Lane lot and 35 municipal spaces in the Oceanport Avenue lot. The same page lists resident rates for the Ayers Lane lot of $3 a day, $200 for six months or $360 a year. The municipal lot is resident-only at $200 for six months or $360 a year, and NJ Transit notes that rates and availability can change.
Train schedules are also off their usual pattern through next week. Since Sunday, October 11, North Jersey Coast Line service has run on adjusted schedules while Amtrak moves the final track onto the new Portal North Bridge. Some trains have been consolidated or canceled, and others have different departure times or stops. The adjusted timetables are posted at njtransit.com/portalcutover. NJ Transit says regular schedules are expected to return on Sunday, November 15, subject to completion of safety testing. Until then, check the posted times before planning a morning stop at the market.
Next on the Borough Calendar
The next big date in town is a few blocks up Prospect Avenue. The borough has scheduled its Holiday Tree Lighting for Sunday, December 6, from 4 to 5 p.m. at Borough Hall, 480 Prospect Ave. The same calendar has a separate listing at 484 Prospect Ave., next door, called "Post Office Museum Open After Tree Lighting," with a 4 p.m. start time. The pizzeria stays open until 10 p.m., so dinner on Ayers Lane fits after the lighting.
The license sat in pocket status for five years before Locale put it to use at 51 Oceanport Ave. If you own near Oceanport Avenue or Ayers Lane and want to know what changes like this mean for your street, Ten Hoeve Advisory knows this part of town block by block. Get in touch, and we'll walk you through it.