Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
A cozy coastal neighborhood restaurant with oak tables, charcoal seating and simple place settings beside a window on a cool late-autumn afternoon.

Once the Seafarer Closes, Three Bay Avenue Kitchens Cover Every Night in Highlands

November 19, 2026

The Seafarer's website has been cut down to a thank-you and a date. "Thank you for an incredible 2026 season!" it reads, and below that: "We will Re-open on Friday April 30th 2027." Under that is one more line, for anyone who wants to put the restaurant under a tree: Christmas gift cards are sold by phone at (732) 861-1741.

Highlands restaurants close in a set order, and most of them post their dates. From Thanksgiving week to the end of April, the town has a fixed sequence of last nights and reopenings. Once the seasonal places are dark, a few Bay Avenue kitchens post hours that, taken together, cover every night of the week.

Here is that sequence in calendar order, starting with what has already closed.

Already Closed Until Spring

The Seafarer at 1 Atlantic Street calls itself a spring, summer and fall restaurant. It is already booking private parties for 2027, with inquiries going to [email protected]. Its reopening date of Friday, April 30, 2027, is the first firm spring date in town.

The Sandbox at Seastreak Beach, 326 Shore Drive, posted "See You Next Spring!" on October 29 and has not given an opening date for 2027. Moby's Freeze at 2 South Bay Avenue runs a May through October season, seven days a week from 11:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. when the weather allows. All three are now closed for the winter.

Bay Avenue also has one permanent change. Saltwater Bar & Kitchen by Big Mike at 128 Bay Avenue has closed for good after two years, as New Jersey 101.5 reported. The Highlands Business Partnership's dining directory still lists it, so skip that entry when you plan a night out.

Saturday, November 21: The Last Farmers Market

The borough calendar lists the Highlands Farmers Market at Huddy Park every Saturday through November 21. That puts the final market two days after this post goes up and five days before Thanksgiving. It's the last outdoor food date on the town's calendar until the tree lighting.

Thanksgiving Weekend Belongs to The Chubby Pickle

Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26. The Chubby Pickle, at 23 Bay Avenue, has already filled the three nights after it. Its November calendar lists Emo Night with DJ Deen on Friday, November 27, at 9 p.m.; Dave Urbano at 7 p.m. and En Delirium at 9 p.m. on Saturday, November 28; and a JTrain Holiday Jazz Show at 5 p.m. on Sunday, November 29.

The Sunday show starts at dinner hour, which suits a household that still has relatives in town. On ordinary weeks, the pub posts weekday happy hour from 3 to 6 p.m., Monday through Friday, Taco Tuesday at three for $12, and burger specials on Wednesday trivia nights. None of those depend on the season.

Friday, December 4: Huddy Park Again

The town comes back to Huddy Park for the annual tree lighting on Friday, December 4, at 6 p.m. The Highlands Business Partnership lists Santa, hot chocolate and goodies, carriage rides and performances. The rain date is Saturday, December 5.

A 6 p.m. start leaves time for dinner afterward, and early December is still a month with more open dining rooms than January or February will have.

December 31: One Willow's Last Night Until Spring

One Willow, the seafood and raw bar restaurant at 1 Willow Street, is promoting New Year's Eve dinner on December 31, 2026, and asks diners to confirm the holiday hours and menu by phone. The same post says the restaurant closes for January and February and reopens in the spring.

So December is the last month to get to One Willow before 2027 is well underway. If it's your usual spot for a family dinner during the holidays, book it in the next six weeks, because the next chance comes after the cold months.

January Through April: Three Bay Avenue Kitchens Cover the Week

After New Year's, the most useful information in Highlands is three posted schedules on Bay Avenue. Taken together, their posted hours cover all seven nights.

Sea & Sand Indian Fusion at 231 Bay Avenue opened in October 2025, as The Monmouth Journal reported. Its own site lists hours of 4 to 9 p.m. on Sunday, Monday, Wednesday and Thursday, 4 to 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday, and closed Tuesday.

Chilangos at 272 Bay Avenue lists Tuesday through Sunday, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., and is closed Monday.

Porcini at 168 Bay Avenue currently lists 4 to 9 p.m. Wednesday and Thursday, 4 to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and 4 to 9 p.m. Sunday.

Put the three side by side and the gaps close. On Monday, Sea & Sand is open while Chilangos and Porcini are closed. On Tuesday, Chilangos is open, and so is The Chubby Pickle's Taco Tuesday a few blocks toward the water. From Wednesday through Sunday, all three Bay Avenue kitchens post dinner hours, and Chilangos also posts lunch. For a midweek dinner in February without crossing the bridge, the street has an answer every night.

The schedules above are the ones these restaurants post on their own sites now. Before a weeknight in January, a quick call is worth the minute, because off-season hours can shift with the weather.

The Waterfront Rooms That Answer the Phone

Bahrs Landing, at 2 Bay Avenue, is listed as "Open year round 7 days a week for lunch and dinner" in the Highlands Business Partnership dining directory. The hours on Bahrs' own homepage, 11:30 a.m. to 8:30 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Sunday, are labeled summer hours. Treat those times as a starting point and call before you go.

The Proving Ground at 56 Shrewsbury Avenue is taking online reservations this month. Off the Hook is at 1 NJ-36, and its number is (732) 872-2006.

Inlet Cafe's First Winter Back

Inlet Cafe at 3 Cornwall Street matters more this off-season than in most years. The Lentz family opened it in 1966. It came back this spring after a closure of roughly three years, with second-generation owners Douglas Lentz and Robin Lentz-Sundstrom running it, according to NJ.com. The Asbury Park Press also covered the reopening in July.

NJ.com described the restaurant as lunch and dinner with a raw bar, smoked fish dip, fish and chips, lobster rolls and dock-and-dine service. It also has Sandy Hook Bay views, a large outdoor seating area and an indoor bar. This is its first cold season since the family returned. The cafe's website says "Lentz Family is back!" and asks diners to call (732) 872-9764 for current hours. Make that call before a December lunch.

April 30 and May: The Seasonal Spots Return

The Seafarer reopens on Friday, April 30, 2027. Moby's Freeze follows in May, when its posted season starts again.

For more on the borough, see our Highlands neighborhood page. For the beach town just over the bridge, see our Sea Bright page.

The team at Ten Hoeve Advisory is based in Monmouth County, with offices in Holmdel and Tinton Falls, and we keep track of these Highlands dates because the people we work with ask about them. If you're hosting family over the holidays and want a recommendation for a quiet table near the water, or you'd like to talk about anything else in town, Get in Touch.

Follow Us On Instagram